As school leaders approaching BSF or PCP, you'll have to grasp not only the three spatial dimensions of your new building - but also the vital fourth dimension, time. Join John Davitt as he learns from a group of cutting-edge "timetablists".
BSF offers the opportunity to learn
from the past and build for the future. It also presents the challenge
of how to make the most of this one-off opportunity. We know from
experience you can't legislate to learn, or design the perfect learning
space in a vacuum.
To any new school building, however delightful, we
must always add the choreography of curriculum and the grammar of
timetabling. In the end it is the interplay of space, subject and time
that will determine how any learning opportunities proceed.
But
are these parameters as fixed as we thought? With the publication of
the latest guidance for school construction (BB98), and Building School
for the Future exemplification work on school environments, might there
be a little more freedom to do things in new ways, to free up time and
space by doing things a little bit differently? Might the BB98 building
guidance serve more as a compass than a straitjacket as schools plan
new curricula and new learning spaces?
To answer this
question, a group of visionary head teachers, curriculum clear-thinkers
and timetabling specialists gathered in London for an inaugural meet at
the end of 2008. Their aim was to find the correct 'grammar' to
describe
learning opportunities and lay them out in time, beyond the rigidities
of "all year 9 doing science or PE on a Wednesday".
Many of the
speakers were convinced that if we can organise space, time, and
movement in new ways in our schools, learning opportunities will be
heightened, resources released into community learning and barriers to
learning reduced.
The group was also aware that new ways of timetabling
are hard to articulate, having something of the "fo

urth dimension"
about them. Inspiration for the group's formation, and for their journey
across this tricky and hard to articulate ground where time meets
curriculum, came from Paul Mortimer (right), principal designate of the new
Isle of Sheppey Academy.
Paul Mortimer introduced the day by describing
the need for a "fuzzy logic" approach to some problems where you have
to proceed using imprecise data if you are to move forward. He then
went on to describe how creative timetabling and BB98 has allowed him
to release funds to construct a school theatre - a much-needed
community resource.
In part this was achieved by acknowledging that
the school would be unable to house all students at the same time and
to build the resource with time-shifting in mind. Paul now even uses
Bloom's Taxonomy (a classification system for learning objectives) as a
planning tool with architects – so that the space is defined at outset
by the various learning uses to which it may be put.
The issue
of individual subjects – and classroom land-grabs by particular
departments – was also highlighted in the group, with the consensus
emerging that the move will be towards "teachers of children, rather
than subjects".
It was acknowledged by all that there will
be tensions between trying to impose central order and the attempt to
free schools up from past conventions of timetabling via departments
that took away some of the flexibility to explore vertical streaming
and a range of usage beyond the "subject silo".
Frank Green, chief executive of the Leigh Technology Academy, noted the
success with models of small schools and vertical timetables
within the umbrella of a larger institution: "Four head teachers, three
small schools," he noted within his own Academy. In past industrial
models, said Frank, "It was necessary for only 20 percent of
students to succeed in school to keep the economy afloat" – but this
has
now been reversed and "80 percent must succeed at least!"
Beware hidden inflexibilities
William
Cotterell, headteacher at Homewood School and Sixth Form Centre,
Kent, described how the five-term year, and the June year start made space and
time for a raft of other innovative pursuits including a nursery on
site. In addition, he warned, even the best opportunities to extend the range
and purpose of learning "can be squashed by
inflexibilities in areas such as transport links". They are now
looking at bus passes for students so they can stay later when needed.
Jackie
Valin from Southfields Community College, Wandsworth runs a state
comprehensive in a selective authority. The school has timetabled a
literacy recovery programme with the provision of themed opportunities
and with extra support phonics and English. When students are ready
personalised time tables are provided. Jackie also articulated a key
question for the group. "With students outside of school for large
periods of time - how do we accredit the learning done and how does
timetabling accommodate this."
In Shakepeare's
Macbeth, the central
character wonders if the very environment will give him away. He fears
that "the very stones prate of my whereabout". Well, it turns out that the
stones won't but the seats might. During the presentation of BSF from
we heard from Beech Williamson, design manager at Partnerships for
Schools, sensors in chairs will allow us to gather data on occupancy and
movement.

At the start of his presentation, Beech (left) said that schools
should not be ruled by the schedules of accommodation at the back of
BB98. His advice was to 'tear and throw'. The key message for schools
is that it doesn't have to be prescriptive or constraining.
Beech
also described a range of building approaches and said that we are
still short on concordances of behaviours and activities we want for
our classrooms. In one sense and these are probably as important as
the cast off tables for space or the comb charts for checking the logic
of traditional timetables.
At close we heard from Keith Johnson,
a specialist in the art of time and space that "Timetabling by its
nature is an activity in pursuit of the impossible – perfection".
But all
agreed that this amalgam of ideas was worth exploring more deeply and
follow up meeting is to be arranged. Watch this space.
Anyone wishing to contribute to Paul Mortimer's group should send an email to bsfteam@ncsl.org.uk